|
What passes for literature nowadays is simple: a data-miner gathers all the material; a legend is recycled (forget Wagner respectfully recycling the Eddas; we are talking pulp and dump here); cliches are mixed in -- to form a crab cake (sold for a mere 7.99 at finest establishments.) Ooops, I forgot: a professional editor from a large publishing house is brought in to create the action-oriented landscape-depicting, technical-manual-quoting mumble (Ask youself: why Rollins sounds just like Patterson? and King? and Parks? and Newsweek?) Mr. Rollins is a parasite: he exploits the woefully uneducated, but instead of letting the reader learn and grow he waves a net of poor research and destructive pseudo-ethics -- and covers it all with the trademark phrase: "Trust me, I am a veterinarian." Rollins' saga is barely passable. A Fish and Game ranger (even with the Green-est Beret background) escaping two professional killers? -- As passable as the President of the US killing a man with his bare hands ('Air Force One', a.k.a "they will swallow anything") I have no idea how Rollins scored on his biochemistry tests (hopefully, poor -- or there is no truth in testing) but the twenty or so genes that encode proteins that make glucose from glycogen are INDEED present in all mammals BECAUSE we store glucose as glycogen -- and disassemble it whenever we need sugar. Using this as the explanation of cryostasis in the arctic frog (or in "grendels" -- or in humans) is pitiable. The name of the ice-station is, apparently such a big deal that it is repeated several times in its original Russian (printed in Cyrillic) -- Grendel... Grendel... Grendel... Clearly, the fact-checker didn't bother to wake up that morning. In Russian the name of the creature is GrendeL' (two letters are used: "L" and "SOFT SIGN") -- nobody would call this station Grendel-with-a-hard-L. (Funny: in Rollins' ancestral language (Polish) there is an L and an L-slash. He should know better... but once again he chose the barely passable. I can almost hear the dialog: "But in Russian 'Grendel' is spelled with 8 letters" -- "That's too confusing. The unwashed masses won't understand.) Admittingly, Russian is hard and the culture of Russia/USSR may be irrelevant. This may explain the insufferable cliches: FSB/KGB is running the country; Fleet Admiral reads (but what else?) 'Brothers Karamazov' before attempting to destroy the world; a submarine CO (a thirty year old Captain (?!) is sarcastic while talking to a Fleet Admiral. Americans are as bad as Russians (Operation Paper Clip etc.) but win nonetheless. My biggest problem with this frosted fiction is not its paper-pulp-back-fiction quality. This is, after all, a 7.99-window-or-aisle-book. The problem is its lack of morals. I don't believe Rollins even understands what's at stake. A child is frozen alive in an OBVIOUSLY criminally inethical experiment (similar to what Nazi "doctors" did to POW) but everything ends happily: the kid is defrosted and is damn happy with his adoptive parents. A veterinarian may not see the finer point here: ANY criminal experiment on ONE human being is a catastrophy for ALL humanity. Making it into a (barely passable) happy ending borders on cheering for the Nazis: what we do is inethical but it still ends well. This is (1) a surreptitious justification for playing God. To Rollins science is omni-benevolent: even a criminally-warped science will somehow lead us to justice. After all, bad guy Craig is punished, and the frozen kid is happy (Maybe Rollins should read some Dostoyevsky: "if there is no God than everything is allowable." = When scientists play God then everything is allowable?! Because it will all sort itself out?!) (2) this also lends a hand to the Bible-thumpers of all sorts: see, folks, if not for the miracle (God's intervention) the kid would've been lost and evil would've not been punished. (Brilliant! It will sell to both the religious right and the scientistic left! Congrats, Mr.(Dr.) Rollins!) There *was* a simple (and ethically acceptable) save -- but Rollings is not a good enough writer to consider it: turn the kid into a character, not a cliche. Have him suffer from nightmares (after all, his consciousness was awake for 60 years!), cry for his mother, develop cold sores and unexplained sadness. Make the reader understand: any attempt to "play God" -- or to "know exactly what God intends" is harmful and the harm is lasting. Grade: F+. A perfect example of 'literature' borne out by the self-perpetuating lack of education and foresight in our society. There is no reason to read Mr.(Dr.) Rollins when Jules Verne is still in print. (There was a man who honestly wanted to educate his reader.) Side note. Want to *learn* something? Want to be *more* human? Read the *real* Grendel, a very decent book by John Champlin Gardner (ISBN: 0679723110) Available at Amazon used for 2.92. Written in a lucid modern English. Final note. I am not a vet-basher. I just think that Rollins lacks a finer understanding of the human species.
|